logoalt Hacker News

charcircuityesterday at 9:14 PM1 replyview on HN

>Linus can't close the kernel.

That's not how it works. GPL only prevents old versions from becoming closed source. If Linus added code to the kernel which required a $100k license to redistribute then people could no longer freely distribute the code of the kernel. People could not freely distribute compile kernels because they would need that license. GPL doesn't magically make all licensing issues go away. He could also make a required kernel module that was not GPL licensed that Linux could require to operate.

>Except there is no device with free drivers that it supports.

Having a working system providing competitive value to others is much more important.

>They just refuse to support Librem or Pinephone without a good reason.

The good reason is that those devices can't provide industry standard security.


Replies

fsfloveryesterday at 10:42 PM

> GPL only prevents old versions from becoming closed source.

This is false, https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html#LinkingWithGPL

> Having a working system providing competitive value to others is much more important.

I don't consider dependence on Google as "working for the users".

> The good reason is that those devices can't provide industry standard security.

Obeying Google is not "security", even if it's the industry standard.

show 1 reply