logoalt Hacker News

ThrowawayR2today at 1:38 AM1 replyview on HN

The Story of Mel counts against the narrative because Mel was so overwhelmingly skilled that he was easily able to outdo the optimizing compiler.


Replies

sanderjdtoday at 3:59 PM

I don't think that does count against the narrative? The narrative is just that each time we've moved up the abstraction chain in generating code, there have been people who have been skeptical of the new level of abstraction. I would say that it's usually the case that highly skilled operators at the previous level remain more effective than the new adopters of the next level. But what ends up mattering more in the long run is that the higher level of abstraction enables a lot more people to get started and reach a basic level of capability. This is exactly what's happening now! Lots of experienced programmers are not embracing these tools, or are, but are still more effective just writing code. But way more people can get into "vibe coding" with some basic level of success, and that opens up new possibilities.

show 1 reply