logoalt Hacker News

vintermannyesterday at 1:11 PM6 repliesview on HN

It's a prediction. Not a terribly unreasonable one as far as I can see. If a drug can move 5% of the ~trillion dollars spent on groceries in the US, there's a lot of money available for clawing those 5% back.

Demanding evidence for predictions like this is a bit... hm. Arrogant, maybe. A prediction is a commitment. We want people to make predictions. The evidence we get when those predictions come true or not. Would you be willing to make the opposite prediction?


Replies

dominicqyesterday at 1:17 PM

There are sometimes truly bizarre demands for evidence. I once posted a pure opinion piece -- essentially a moral judgment on what is good and what is bad (in the domain of technical writing) -- and got hit with "source?"

Me.

I am the source.

brokensegueyesterday at 1:28 PM

Why wouldn't they have already been looking for a way to make their food more palatable? There was already a lot of money on the line

show 1 reply
semiquaveryesterday at 2:35 PM

The figure isn’t 5% of all grocery spending, it’s a 5% household change after one member starts GLP-1.

show 1 reply
hyperpapeyesterday at 1:39 PM

I predict you’ll retract this comment.

I don’t have any evidence that you will, but since you seem to think that’s ok, here goes!

show 2 replies
delfinomyesterday at 1:18 PM

They'll be hard pressed to find something that isn't running into medical regulation territory.

show 1 reply
idiotsecantyesterday at 1:18 PM

Wanting evidence for random claims is arrogant? I'd say magical thinking is whats arrogant.

show 1 reply