logoalt Hacker News

throwfaraway135today at 11:58 AM3 repliesview on HN

I agree with the sentiment, but unfortunately often this is too simplistic.

For example, a lot of Palestinians are not tolerant towards LGBT people -> a lot of LGBT people are not tolerant towards Israelis -> a lot of Israelis are not tolerant towards Palestinians.

Also how do you know if you are intolerant or intolerant towards intolerance?


Replies

pluralmonadtoday at 12:56 PM

> Also how do you know if you are intolerant or intolerant towards intolerance?

You don't need to, it's all intolerance.

obliotoday at 1:42 PM

Nitpick: it's LGBT. I think in Arabic the P and B sounds are kind of the same thing so I understand where the confusion might be coming from.

show 1 reply
ignoramoustoday at 12:26 PM

> I agree with the sentiment, but unfortunately often this is too simplistic. For example, a lot of Palestinians are not tolerant towards LGPT people -> a lot of LGPT people are not tolerant towards Israelis -> a lot of Israelis are not tolerant towards Palestinians.

Nice bait with broad sweeping generalizations there.

One of critiques of "Paradox of Tolerance" is its proponents (probably not Karl Popper himself) take the argument to its extremes (similar to the generalization you posit), while the reality is more of a spectrum.

show 2 replies