logoalt Hacker News

arghwhattoday at 12:51 PM2 repliesview on HN

It's not the power demand that is the problem.

It's that the majority of AI deployments are happening in a country which has a has had very poor renewable adoption and is now actively sabotaging renewable projects with an active opposition to climate goals because a particular group wants to protect their existing revenue.

Renewables are cheap and highly profitable, and money talks - even in the US, as can be seen in Texas. But it's hard to fight against your government when they want to force you to buy their rich friends' fossil fuels instead...


Replies

cmiles8today at 1:35 PM

This is a pretty gross mis characterization of what’s happening. There’s been a lot written about the fluff that is a lot of these AI company “purchases” of “green” energy. In practice there’s no way to get that power from (insert middle of nowhere location with green energy plant) to (insert location of AI datacenter) so to actually power the data center the utility is forced to power on some clunky old coal plant to keep the chips powered.

The AI company is issuing press releases saying how they bought all this clean power but in practice they just forced some old clunky power plants back online to meet their demand.

show 1 reply
dangustoday at 1:03 PM

Exactly this. Powering all AI data centers with renewable energy is actually trivially easy.

You could even legislate it and make big tech companies responsible for providing the power themselves. One stroke of the pen resolves the issue.

If OpenAI can afford to “spend $1 trillion” on AI they can afford to build some wind/solar/battery power plants.

show 4 replies