logoalt Hacker News

bboryesterday at 7:04 PM1 replyview on HN

  democratic states like Iran
...whelp, this thread is gonna get shut down. Everyone was being reasonable, but all it takes is one person to say some out-of-pocket shit like "the country currently massacring protestors is the real democracy" for it to descend below HN's standards for political discourse.

  non-democratic states like north korea
And FWIW, the Democratic People's Republic of Korea is ostensibly a democracy, too. AFAIR the list of openly non-democratic states is quite small: Saudi Arabia, some microstates like the Holy See, and ~6 non-micro "Executive constitutional monarchies" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitutional_monarchy#List_o...)

Replies

hearsathoughtyesterday at 7:12 PM

> ...whelp, this thread is gonna get shut down.

No. It's about iran, so it'll get stuck on the frontpage for a while. If this was about israel, then you'd have point.

> but all it takes is one person to say some out-of-pocket shit like "the country currently massacring protestors is the real democracy" for it to descend below HN's standards for political discourse.

The US has massacred people, even protestors. Are you saying we are not a democracy?

> And FWIW, the Democratic People's Republic of Korea is ostensibly a democracy, too.

There is a difference between one claiming to be a democracy and another that actually is. No?

show 1 reply