None of this is fresh in my mind, so my recollections might be a little hazy. I think the only issue I personally had when writing a decoder was keeping the alignment of various fields right. I wrote the decoder in C# and if I remember correctly I tried to get fancy with some modern-ish deserialization code. I think I eventually resorted to writing a rather ugly but simple low-level byte reader. Nevertheless I found it to be a relatively straightforward program to write and I got most of what I wanted done in under a day.

The vibe coded version was a different story. For simplicity, I wanted to stick to an early version of BMP. I don’t remember the version off the top of my head. This was a simplified implementation for students to use and modify in a class setting. Sticking to early version BMPs also made it harder for students to go off-piste since random BMPs found on the internet probably would not work.

The main problem was that the LLM struggled to stick to a specific version of BMP. Some of those newer features (compression, color table, etc, if I recall correctly) have to be used in a coordinated way. The LLM made a real mess here, mixing and matching newer features with older ones. But I did not understand that this was the problem until I gave up and started writing things myself.