logoalt Hacker News

Nextgridtoday at 10:24 AM3 repliesview on HN

> with redundant power, cooling, etc

The doors the system controls don't have any of this. Hell, the whole building doesn't have any of this. And it definitely doesn't have redundant internet connections to the cloud-based control plane.

This is fear-mongering when a passive PC running a container image on boot will suffice plenty. For updates a script that runs on boot and at regular intervals that pulls down the latest image with a 30s timeout if it can't reach the server.


Replies

onlitoday at 10:47 AM

What updates? That would be on a local network and have no internet connection, if done right.

show 2 replies
Telemakhostoday at 10:57 AM

You know what else would suffice plenty? Physical keys and mechanical locks. They worked (and still work) without electricity. The tech is mature and well-understood.

show 2 replies
lazidetoday at 10:48 AM

Those devices can be trivially power cycled, and won’t have as many issues with dodgy power. Some PC somewhere with storage is a bigger problem.

show 1 reply