logoalt Hacker News

RobotToasteryesterday at 4:00 PM4 repliesview on HN

This adds some more context I guess https://chaos.social/@North/115605819126197877

Honestly the whole thing seems like everyone overreacting on both sides. Accusing someone is "doxing" because they used your first name?


Replies

suobsetyesterday at 5:55 PM

The collections of threads, statements, and accusations on both sides are some of the most unhinged things I have seen in a while, and I don't think any of this helps anyone. :')

buildbotyesterday at 4:02 PM

I believe they are claiming doxing based on connecting an email to a social media account.

show 1 reply
rincebrainyesterday at 5:02 PM

I don't have a bone in this race, but if someone has deliberately hidden their identity online, knowingly disclosing that is malicious, regardless of any other morality involved.

Consider people who have their public persona very deliberately obfuscated, like Banksy, or Chuck Tingle - it's very intentional that both of them do not disclose that, and if you found out either of their legal names, and disclosed it publicly, it would be with deliberate intent to subvert them.

Or consider if someone posted online they had a beer, and they lived somewhere that considered that an egregious crime even if they did it somewhere that it was legal. If you deliberately released proof that the person posting "I had a beer" was this person, it would have malicious intent, regardless of how you feel about the morality of beer.

show 1 reply
relaxingyesterday at 4:36 PM

Buried in there is the Sparkfun guy did in fact register a vanity domain and stand up a site for the purpose of harassing the Adafruit guy.

Kind of shitty to play the victim at that point.

show 2 replies