logoalt Hacker News

sfinkyesterday at 6:22 PM0 repliesview on HN

It did not contribute to a yes/no answer, which is good, because it is not answerable with "yes" or "no", and the article points that out and explains why. So I would disagree; it does contribute to answering the question, in the form of spelling out why it is unanswerable.

Compare:

"Have you stopped beating your wife yet?"

"I do not beat my wife."

The response contributes to the answer, even if it brings you no closer to "yes" or "no".