logoalt Hacker News

juancnyesterday at 7:30 PM4 repliesview on HN

It feels like this would backfire.

I mean, UV light is carcinogenic, and environments that are way too clean, are fine for surgery or manufacturing semiconductors, but for most humans (specially children) they can be counter-productive.

The immune system needs something to train on and fight, otherwise you end up with autoimmune diseases and all sorts of crap.

We're essentially walking ecosystems that can easily be imbalanced.


Replies

wffurryesterday at 7:42 PM

>> The immune system needs something to train on and fight, otherwise you end up with autoimmune diseases and all sorts of crap.

If you want to train your childrens' immune system, get a dog. Don't intentionally expose them to pathenogenic viruses like COVID or the flu. https://www.science.org/content/article/want-fight-allergies...

elil17yesterday at 7:35 PM

Far UVC is not carcinogenic (most UV is, this is just a specific wavelength that isn't).

Ideally you'd want to use these lamps in environments that our immune systems didn't evolve for, like crowded conference rooms and school classrooms.

show 1 reply
Retz4o4yesterday at 10:19 PM

Not the same wavelength as UV. This wavelength is blocked by your skin - and outer layer of your eyeballs!

selfsimilaryesterday at 7:40 PM

The best training for immune robustness is going outside and get exposure to a wide range of stuff. But for indoor spaces, air quality is going to be dominated by the microbes and viruses of the people in the space itself. For public spaces and shared residential spaces with poor airflow this would be great - grocery stores, nursing homes, etc. For condos, apartments, SFH, etc. it's probably less necessary, but probably wouldn't hurt. Or nice to have when company comes over, or someone in the house is sick and "polluting" the air.