logoalt Hacker News

rbanffyyesterday at 8:23 PM4 repliesview on HN

All it needs is an experiment that can test it.


Replies

Animatsyesterday at 8:56 PM

High-energy physics is kind of stuck on that. Most of the interesting questions involve energies or distances way beyond what's reachable by experiment today.

Meanwhile, there's interesting experimental action in low-energy physics, down near absolute zero. Many of the weirder predictions of quantum mechanics have now been observed directly. Look at the list of Nobel laureates in physics since 1990. A big fraction of them involve experiments with very low energy states, where thermal noise is small enough that quantum effects dominate. Some of that work led to useful technology. That's forward progress.

show 2 replies
ekjhgkejhgkyesterday at 8:43 PM

One day when I'm not being lazy I might publish a point by point refutation of the usual nonsense anti-string theory memes. Until then, here's what I said on this point 25 days ago, specifically the first paragraph starting with "like another commenter".

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46336655

show 2 replies
slashdaveyesterday at 9:10 PM

Provide a viable test, and you will be sure that an experimentalist will jump at the chance

qoezyesterday at 8:31 PM

If they had that the hype could die. Luckily it cannot be tested so the hype will continue in perpetuity

show 1 reply