logoalt Hacker News

dvtyesterday at 11:59 PM2 repliesview on HN

Implementing an allowlist is pretty common practice for just about anything that accesses external stuff. Heck, Windows Firewall does it on every install. It's a bit of friction for a lot of security.


Replies

acjohnson55today at 2:23 AM

But it's actually a tremendous amount of friction, because it's the difference between being able to let agents cook for hours at a time or constantly being blocked on human approvals.

And even then, I think it's probably impossible to prevent attacks that combine vectors in clever ways, leading to people incorrectly approving malicious actions.

wat10000today at 12:08 AM

It's also pretty common for people to want their tools to be able to access a lot of external stuff.

From Anthropic's page about this:

> If you've set up Claude in Chrome, Cowork can use it for browser-based tasks: reading web pages, filling forms, extracting data from sites that don't have APIs, and navigating across tabs.

That's a very casual way of saying, "if you set up this feature, you'll give this tool access to all of your private files and an unlimited ability to exfiltrate the data, so have fun with that."