logoalt Hacker News

bfleschyesterday at 9:48 AM1 replyview on HN

Unfortunately extending benefit of the doubt towards US tech companies is a luxury not everybody can or wants to afford. There is a clear pattern of enshittification of their products.

As you assume that GP has not read the post, how about you?

Because google clearly state that the "high denial rates" are a problem, but their framing of the issue is that the users have a "context gap" which needs to be fixed. Because they are convinced that even though users have decided against geolocation sharing with a specific website they want to get prompted about it over and over again as part of the organic interface of the website. And if they un-block it once over the new interface then the previous block will be forgotten and the permission will forever be granted.

A solution respecting their users would be to allow geolocation for duration of the browser tab, but that is clearly not in line with their data collection goals for their advertisers.


Replies

Crpt774yesterday at 12:25 PM

A permission request every browser session also wouldn't be in line with the needs of the average end user, and would train them to hit accept on any prompt that arises, as if they didn't do that enough anyway.