logoalt Hacker News

anon291today at 8:28 PM7 repliesview on HN

I have no strong feelings towards palantir. But the ones I do have are mostly negative.

However it seems crazy to me that even the idea of deporting people who have no legal status in this country is immediately branded Nazi. This just feeds extremism because it is extremism in and of itself


Replies

hairofadogtoday at 9:25 PM

That's not what's happening. There wouldn't be the backlash if they were primarily deporting "the worst of the worst", as they promised, using due process. Instead they're targeting everyone, including people here legally and in many cases U.S. citizens, without due process, in the cruelest and most over-the-top way possible.

show 1 reply
rcontitoday at 9:23 PM

I have a friend whose parents were just (incorrectly) detained by ICE, and had to pay a $3000 administrative fee to be released.

That _is_ the extremism. It's here.

show 1 reply
swsiebertoday at 9:20 PM

> the idea of deporting people who have no legal status in this country is immediately branded Nazi

It's not just that idea though. Plenty of presidents have done that without pushback. It's that idea combined with:

* Rhetoric dehumanizing the immigrants

* Raiding churches, courts, jobs, etc

* Revoking legal status of immigrants

* Reducing training time for new hires

* Detaining U.S. citizens and threatening them

* Saying it'll help the U.S. citizens, when data shows it doesn't

show 1 reply
tencentshilltoday at 9:19 PM

Even trying to follow the existing law is punishable by exile without trial. You can go to all your legally appointed court dates, follow every rule in the book, and get snatched and deported from the courtroom the next minute.

show 1 reply
Altern4tiveAcctoday at 9:01 PM

> the idea of deporting people who have no legal status in this country is immediately branded Nazi

Because that idea consists of harming someone over their birth circumstances, rather than any objective harm they may have done.

timeontoday at 10:01 PM

My great-grand parents woke one day with status of illegals. Shortly after that they have been included in mass deportations to Poland.

Some people have asked how something like that could happened. Thanks for your comment. Now I can sand them this link as an answer.

insane_dreamertoday at 8:42 PM

People have been deported for decades but the manner in which deportations occur is important. There’s a world of difference between law enforcement and these brownshirts.