logoalt Hacker News

cheese4242yesterday at 8:59 PM1 replyview on HN

If you believe said women is attempting to attack you with a deadly weapon (an accelerating vehicle that you were struck by in this case) that would fall pretty clearly under justified use of force.


Replies

kraquepypeyesterday at 9:59 PM

"If you believe"...

What makes you believe that she had any intent to attempt an attack?

Intent is where this falls apart, as she had no intent to harm with her vehicle. The interaction up until escalation by the agents was peaceful.

Even if the agent was in harms way, "totality of the circumstances" need to be reviewed before it can be said that deadly force was justified (see Barnes v. Felix ruling below)

https://www.shawbransford.com/supreme-court-unanimously-reje...

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/24pdf/23-1239_onjq.pdf