logoalt Hacker News

0xbadcafebee01/16/20261 replyview on HN

I don't think it's possible to make an AI a "Senior Engineer", or even a good engineer, by training it on random crap from the internet. It's got a million brains' worth of code in it. That means bad patterns as well as good. You'd need to remove the bad patterns for it not to "remember" and regurgitate them. I don't think prompts help with this either, it's like putting a band-aid on head trauma.


Replies

HarHarVeryFunny01/16/2026

It's also rather like trying to learn flintnapping just by looking at examples of knapped flint (maybe some better than others), rather than having access to descriptions of how to do it, and ultimately any practice of doing it.

You could also use cooking as an analogy - trying to learn to cook by looking at pictures of cooked food rather than by having gone to culinary school and learnt the principles of how to actually plan and cook good food.

So, we're trying to train LLMs to code, by giving them "pictures" of code that someone else built, rather than by teaching them the principles involved in creating it, and then having them practice themselves.