logoalt Hacker News

mcgannon2007today at 2:16 PM3 repliesview on HN

It isn't an original work, but actually a painted version of a famous engraving by Martin Schongauer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Temptation_of_St_Anthony_(...


Replies

baschtoday at 2:42 PM

I am by no means an expert art historian but I'm not sure I 100% follow the logic of their conclusion.

"pentimenti, or correction marks, a common indication that “a painting is not a copy, but an original work created with artistic freedom.”"

How often are they analyzing copies made by 12 year old. Is a 12 year old more likely to have made errors or drifted from the source during the process of the copy? Could the corrections be attempts to bring the painting closer to its source, because it wasnt close enough?

show 1 reply
BeaverGoosetoday at 3:05 PM

The engraving is much better too. Shame we don't appreciate Schongauer as much as Michelangelo.

show 3 replies
maxbainestoday at 2:31 PM

Thankyou