logoalt Hacker News

KellyCriterionyesterday at 3:42 PM4 repliesview on HN

...and sorry: Thats absolutely OK. I do not want strangers stopping by for 3 - 4 years to be able to influence the politics of my country? Thats totaly understandable?

I would never to ask to vote at a remote place where I do not live permanently, yet where I even not a citizen?


Replies

epistasisyesterday at 4:08 PM

Somebody who spends 3-4 years in a place has an immense interest in how it's governed. Their view is 100% as valid as yours, and they should have equal voice, if we are going to judge people based on how long they live somewhere.

I live in a college town. Why shouldn't student voices be represented, when they are a huge chunk of our community?

Maybe I'm too US focused, and have been accused of that a lot recently, but your views are fundamentally at odds with basic democracy as I see it as a US citizen.

show 2 replies
systemtestyesterday at 3:44 PM

That is OK but OP should not be complaining about people not being engaged with local politics if you are excluding a large part of the people living in the city from voting.

show 2 replies
triceratopsyesterday at 4:02 PM

> I do not want strangers stopping by for 3 - 4 years to be able to influence the politics of my country?

City, not country.

show 1 reply
mattkrauseyesterday at 4:03 PM

What's the minimum residency you'd accept, because 3-4 years seems quite long to me.

show 1 reply