I'll espouse the flip side of this:
I've worked with a handful of excellent QA. In my opinion - the best QA is basically a product manager lite. They understand the user, and they act from the perspective of the user when evaluating new features. Not the "plan" for the feature. The actual implementation provided by development.
This means they clarify edge cases, call out spots that are confusing or tedious for a user, and understand & test how features interact. They help take a first draft of a feature to a much higher level of polish than most devs/pms actually think through, and avoid all sorts of long term problems with shipping features that don't play nicely.
I think it's a huge mistake to ask QA to do automation tests - Planning for them? Sure. Implementation? No. That's a dev's job, you should assign someone with that skillset (and pay them accordingly).
QA is there to drive quality up for your users, the value comes from the opinions they make after using what the devs provide (often repeatedly, like a user) - not from automating that process.
Reminds me of how often I've felt a little envious as a dev of how much influence QA people had on effective specification. Whenever a spec appears a little ambiguous (or contradictory) the QA person becomes judge and their decisions effectively become law.
yes - devs are great at coding so get them to write the tests and then I, a good tester, (not to be confused with QA) can work with them on what are good tests to write. With this in place I can confidently test to find the edge cases, usability issues etc And when I find them we can analyze how the issue could have been caught sooner
Right - the best QA people need only be as technical as your user base. Owning QA environment, doing deploys, automated testing, etc are all the sort of things that can live with a developer.
They are there to protect dev teams from implementing misunderstandings of tickets. In a way a good Product Manager should wear a QA hat themselves, but I've seen fewer good PMs than good QAs....