logoalt Hacker News

proxtoday at 6:05 PM4 repliesview on HN

Just to engage with your “12 year old to produce by yourself” , here are some examples of art made by Picasso in his early teens to mid teens.

It’s absolutely possible to be that good. Especially in the middle ages / early renaissance with the work you did for guilds and working for masters as an apprentice.

At eleven years old: https://www.pablo-ruiz-picasso.net/work-3939.php

At fourteen at his sisters wedding: https://www.pablo-ruiz-picasso.net/work-9.php

At fifteen https://www.pablo-ruiz-picasso.net/work-11.php


Replies

vitrotoday at 7:02 PM

True, no phones, no distractions, I can see someone who finds their passion early on to get this good.

vilhelm_stoday at 6:48 PM

But he had not been an apprentice before making this, he started the apprenticeship that year, and this is supposed to be the first thing he ever painted.

> Michelangelo's biographers—Giorgio Vasari (1511–1574) and Ascanio Condivi (1525–1574)—tell us that, aside from some drawings, his first work was a painted copy after a well-known engraving by Martin Schongauer (1448–1491) showing Saint Anthony tormented by demons. Made about 1487–88 under the guidance of his friend and fellow pupil Francesco Granacci, Michelangelo's painting was much admired; it was even said to have incited Ghirlandaio's envy. [https://www.metmuseum.org/exhibitions/listings/2009/michelan...]

show 1 reply
quotemstrtoday at 6:52 PM

More broadly, we're doing people a disservice today by treating them as juveniles until they graduate college. When someone's that good, we shouldn't waste four years of his life in school he doesn't need, but instead let him be productive immediately out of college.

Christ a-fucking mighty, in some states, the law says that Michelangelo, had he been alive today,would have had to sit on a booster seat at the age at which he made this painting. Absurd.

One of my more heretical beliefs is that tech companies should do more hiring of high brilliant people right out of high school.

show 1 reply
nextaccountictoday at 6:25 PM

> It’s absolutely possible to be that good.

Sure, but not if this is your first painting. Humans can't one-shot art like this

show 1 reply