This is still unsound (in both C and Rust), because the compiler can break data dependencies by e.g. replacing a value with a different value known to be equal to it. A compiler barrier doesn't prevent this. (Neither would a hardware barrier, but with a hardware barrier it doesn't matter if data dependencies are broken.) The difficulty of ensuring the compiler will never break data dependencies is why compilers never properly implemented consume. Yet at the same time, this kind of optimization is actually very rare in non-pathological code, which is why Linux has been able to get away with assuming it won't happen.