logoalt Hacker News

philistinetoday at 1:08 PM1 replyview on HN

Not all historic facts are relevant. Using someone’s old name when relevance can be achieved by stating the person was transgender is preferable.


Replies

reorder9695today at 4:04 PM

I personally prefer not having other people decide for me which facts are and aren't relevant, I think that is unhelpful and potentially dangerous (some people think what happened in Tienanmen Square isn't relevant to the general population, do you agree?).

For a transgender person, I may have known them before they transitioned for example and may not necessarily be familiar with their new name, that's a reason off the top of my head that it would be relevant to me but not necessarily you.

show 4 replies