logoalt Hacker News

listenallyallyesterday at 6:54 PM1 replyview on HN

That's fine - the man was certainly not above being criticized, and he had plenty of flaws. Point is, do it while he's alive, don't wait until he's dead (especially when his death was not a surprise)


Replies

hackyhackyyesterday at 7:02 PM

> do it while he's alive,

Why? Must every obituary be a hagiography?

Adams got plenty of criticism while alive and had plenty of chance to defend himself. He doesn't get a heckler's veto on the living. We are entitled to tell the truth about the dead to ensure the accuracy of their memory.

show 1 reply