logoalt Hacker News

rk06today at 3:07 AM2 repliesview on HN

icons should prioritize usability first,and design, intersting afterwards.

if your users need billboards, then your job is to make great bill boards


Replies

WWLinktoday at 3:43 AM

The current icons really aren't that good. Looking at apple specifically: The facetime and messages icons are almost completely indistinguishable. Get angry and say I'm blind, but so is a lot of the userbase - like legitimately, legally blind people.

The camera icon on iOS is just a fucking camera lens with a grey background. No context.

The calculator one is actually pretty good.

The photos one is also bullshit lol.

show 1 reply
wtetznertoday at 6:42 AM

Sure, but it's not clear they're unrelated. Maybe interesting is necessary (but not sufficient) for usability?

Also, the newer icons don't really indicate a word processing application. If anything, they're look like they might be for a drawing program. So regardless of interesting/abstract/whatever, it seems like a poor icon choice.