logoalt Hacker News

wk_endtoday at 3:40 AM3 repliesview on HN

FWIW: a single car crash killing 21 people would still be newsworthy in America. And I think if you math it out with something per capita equivalent, this would actually be an exceptionally bad day/incident for the US.

But of course you're not wrong, trains are vastly safer than private cars. If anyone uses this as evidence against having a proper rail system, they're ignorant.

But - until someone does that, there's no reason to make this about the US or cars vs. trains. It's borderline offensive to reflexively politicize this before anyone else had; it almost feels like you're intentionally trying to sow conflict, here.


Replies

rubenflamsheptoday at 3:51 AM

~107 people die per day from car accidents in the USA [0].

0. Per 2024 stats from the NHTSA (https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/nhtsa-estimates-39345-t...)

show 1 reply
pfdietztoday at 4:30 AM

https://international-railway-safety-council.com/safety-stat...

In Europe, trains are 28 times safer than cars (fatalities per passenger-km).

angra_mainyutoday at 5:00 AM

The discourse here is more of a criticism of Puentes, who is a very controversial minister overseeing this.