logoalt Hacker News

fuzzer371today at 4:24 AM7 repliesview on HN

No one uses em dashes


Replies

dragonwritertoday at 4:58 AM

If nobody used em-dashes, they wouldn’t have featured heavily in the training set for LLMs. It is used somewhat rarely (so e people use it a lot, others not at all) in informal digital prose, but that’s not the same as being entirely unused generally.

crimonytoday at 4:48 AM

Microsoft Word automatically converts dashes to em dashes as soon as you hit space at the end of the next word after the dash.

show 1 reply
schrodingertoday at 4:52 AM

I do—all the time. Why not?

I also use en dashes when referring to number ranges, e.g., 1–9

show 1 reply
rmunntoday at 4:46 AM

Except for Emily Dickenson, who is an outlier and should not be counted.

Seriously, she used dashes all the time. Here is a direct copy and paste of the first two stanzas of her poem "Because I count not stop for Death" from the first source I found, https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/47652/because-i-could...

  Because I could not stop for Death –
  He kindly stopped for me –
  The Carriage held but just Ourselves –
  And Immortality.

  We slowly drove – He knew no haste
  And I had put away
  My labor and my leisure too,
  For His Civility –
Her dashes have been rendered as en dashes in this particular case rather than em dashes, but unless you're a typography enthusiast you might not notice the difference (I certainly didn't and thought they were em dashes at first). I would bet if I hunted I would find some places where her poems have been transcribed with em dashes. (It's what I would have typed if I were transcribing them).
show 1 reply
awakeasleeptoday at 4:32 AM

Except for highly literate people, and people who care about typography.

Think about it— the robots didn’t invent the em-dash. They’re copying it from somewhere.

show 1 reply
DocTomoetoday at 5:27 AM

Tell me you never worked with LaTeX and an university style guide without telling me you never worked with LaTeX and an university style guide.

show 1 reply