logoalt Hacker News

maqptoday at 8:13 AM9 repliesview on HN

Could someone please explain in what situation do you use a BlueTooth messaging app? Like, even BT5 range won't exceed 400 meters. What good is this? You're not going to send images to journalists from protests with it (you'd do wisely to keep it in airplane mode until you get home and then you'd upload them to their securedrop or whatever), and you don't need off-band security to let the kids know it's dinner time.


Replies

ifwintercotoday at 10:07 AM

In theory if as many people use bitchat as used whatsapp somewhere like central london, everyone actually could communicate in a fully decentralised manner - you're frequently in bluetooth range of other people's phones just walking around or even sat in your house.

Would that actually happen? No, but it's an interesting thought experiment

show 1 reply
zenmactoday at 8:48 AM

One of these bluetooth messaging app was made by a developer who was on a cruise ship with family, and the Internet over satellite costs an arm and leg. So he wrote an app to communicate with his families over bluetooth.

Also why would one want to have the data go over some servers thousands miles away when the device is right next to you? Seems like bluetooth is the perfect way to communicate for devices that are close to each other.

show 5 replies
bcraventoday at 9:33 AM

Back in the 2010s I used the 'Notes' applications to send messages via Bluetooth on my Sony Ericsson to chat with a girl in the next bunk.

There was no signal in the remote Irish hostel so it was the perfect way to send messages covertly in the dormitory.

Fun night!

show 1 reply
yaristoday at 8:24 AM

Any situation when mobile internet cannot be used. That is not only protests, but also legal gatherings, i.e. street concerts, or places where mobile coverage is poor in general.

show 3 replies
behnamohtoday at 8:33 AM

In Iran right now... Internet shut down while the regime keeps slaughtering people at the order of 4x9/11.

show 2 replies
gchokovtoday at 8:24 AM

This particular one supports mesh, so the range could be way way higher.

pbiggartoday at 10:03 AM

Consider if you live in Gaza. Israel has destroyed all the telecoms equipment across the Gaza strip (and everything else). You were ordered to leave your home by Israeli soldiers, but now the school you're sheltering in is being bombed. You may need to leave, but you believe there may be sniper drones outside.

- You want to check in with people around you about what to do - You want to check on the health of your family, from whom you were separated

melting_snowtoday at 8:21 AM

I see two use cases: * Communication between protestors * Illegal activities, but here I can imagine that bluetooth range is too small

show 5 replies