logoalt Hacker News

wongarsuyesterday at 12:49 PM6 repliesview on HN

That's great news. From April onwards buying from a reliable vendor with fulfillment by Amazon will mean you get the parts from that vendor, not some random parts from a random provider that claim to have the same SKU.

Seems like Amazon finally agrees that the counterfeiting issues from commingling are worse than the logistics advantages


Replies

xatttyesterday at 1:02 PM

> Seems like Amazon finally agrees that the counterfeiting issues from commingling are worse than the logistics advantages.

The cynical perspective is that they are facing a serious financial penalty either from the manufacturers themselves, or a large buyer that got burned by co-mingled products, or both.

show 6 replies
itopaloglu83yesterday at 1:30 PM

I bought an LG monitor, by part number, three times and always received the similar looking but half the price counterpart.

We only realized the issue after using it for a few days and needing to use an advance feature.

So, it’s not just one sellers product mingled with another, but also sellers combining similar looking products together as well.

show 1 reply
fn-moteyesterday at 3:04 PM

> From April onwards

Very curious how they are going to clean up their commingled inventory in 2.5 months.

Or do they already know and it will take them that long to implement … whatever?

show 1 reply
dev_l1x_beyesterday at 1:49 PM

This is amazing!! I get what I paid for. Gonna miss the massive amount of garbage that I got instead of the product I wanted to have. What time to be alive.

broheeyesterday at 1:34 PM

It's pretty optimistic. They certainly cannot "uncommingle" existing stock, so you may be able to buy new product with better source assurance, but for existing products...

show 1 reply
Noaidiyesterday at 1:19 PM

Great news? It’s great news that nobody really knew that we were buying items but not receiving them from the person that we bought them from? It’s a logistical advantage to defraud customers? Because this is what Amazon was doing all along, defrauding customers. I never knew that I was receiving an item from someone who I didn’t purchase it from how is that even legal?

show 2 replies