logoalt Hacker News

ckastneryesterday at 3:19 PM2 repliesview on HN

> To call training illegal is similar to calling reading a book and remembering it illegal.

Perhaps, but reproducing the book from this memory could very well be illegal.

And these models are all about production.


Replies

roblablayesterday at 3:26 PM

To be fair, that seems to be where some of the IA lawsuits are going. The argument goes that the models themselves aren't derivative works, but the output they produce can absolutely be - in much the same way that reproducing a book from memory could be copyright violation, trademark infringement, or generally go afoul of the various IP laws.

threethirtytwoyesterday at 3:47 PM

Models don’t reproduce books though. It’s impossible for a model to reproduce something word for word because the model never copied the book.

Most of the best fit curve runs along a path that doesn’t even touch an actual data point.

show 3 replies