logoalt Hacker News

pixl97yesterday at 8:39 PM1 replyview on HN

Yea, causation here depends on a whole lot.

If you're movement is going to 100% cause a reaction of violence with the opposition regardless if you're violent or not, then there is zero reason for your movement not to use violence themselves. Simply put, you'd be rounded up and exterminated simply for existing.


Replies

throw0101dyesterday at 8:43 PM

> If you're movement is going to 100% cause a reaction of violence with the opposition regardless if you're violent or not, then there is zero reason for your movement not to use violence themselves. Simply put, you'd be rounded up and exterminated simply for existing.

The book covers such scenarios: where you are non-violent but the Powers That Be are violent towards your movement.