logoalt Hacker News

asdffyesterday at 11:38 PM3 repliesview on HN

We do select for a more resistant wing. How did we determine that this wing is more resistant? We modeled its bending tolerance and selected this particular design against other designs that had worse evaluated results for bending tolerance.


Replies

hollowturtletoday at 12:28 AM

And that, my friend, is just engineering, like I said above it's an iterative process. There is no "natural selection" from random shaped wings

xg15today at 12:27 AM

First, how did we model the bending tolerance if everything is just randomness?

Second, there are other algorithms that constructively find a solution and don't work at all like genetic algorithms, such as mathematical solvers.

Third, sometimes, a design is also simply thought up by a human, based on their own professional skills and past experience.

troupotoday at 6:32 AM

Yes, and it was an intentional process.

Natural selectiom:

- is not an intentional process

- does not find "the strongest the fittest the fastest etc."