logoalt Hacker News

lucb1etoday at 8:31 AM4 repliesview on HN

> 3. I allow students to discuss among themselves [during an exam] if it is on topic.

Makes me wonder if they should also get a diploma together then, saying "may not have the tested knowledge if not accompanied by $other_student"

I know of some companies that support hiring people as a team (either all or none get hired and they're meant to then work together well), so it wouldn't necessarily be a problem if they wish to be a team like that


Replies

ploumtoday at 8:51 AM

OP here: I teach Open Source Strategies.

The main strategy is collaboration. If you are smart enough to:

1. Identify your problem 2. Ask someone about it 3. Get an answer which improve your understanding

Then you are doing pretty good by all standards

Another trick I sometimes use. I take one student which has hard time articulate it a concept. I take student two who don’t understand that concept. I say to student 1: "You have 20 minutes to teach student 2 the concept. When I come back, you will be graded according to his answers"

(I, of course, not only grade that. But it forces both of them to make an extra effort, student 2 not willing to be the cause for student 1 demise)

witchertoday at 8:33 AM

Yea, curious too about some more rules e.g. both parties has to contribute to the discussion (:

kubbtoday at 8:35 AM

I think we should send all diplomas to OpenAI and end higher education.

Less educated people are easier to steer via TikTok feeds anyway.

elbcitoday at 8:37 AM

ha ha fair enough - but he does mention there's a culture of isolation and cu-throat competition at the school so, maybe it's just a reaction to that