logoalt Hacker News

mooglyyesterday at 4:20 PM2 repliesview on HN

Well then us Europeans are fucked regardless I guess.

> Beijing did not want to see a Russian loss in Ukraine because it feared the United States would then shift its whole focus to Beijing

How does this statement make sense though? I don't see the A -> B. The US pretty clearly does not want to see a Russian loss either, and seems more fine with Ukraine losing.

It should depends on how much the US wants Europe?

If the US does not want more of Europe, and Russia wins, the US could let Russia take over Europe -> focus shifts to China.

If the US wants more of Europe, and Russia wins -> focus would be off China.

If the US does not want more of Europe, and Russia loses -> it's mostly whatever, but perhaps focus shifts to China.

If the US wants more of Europe, and Russia loses -> focus would be off China.

Perhaps I'm just really daft.


Replies

graemepyesterday at 5:17 PM

> Well then us Europeans are fucked regardless I guess

Yes, in some ways. Europe is a LOT less important than it used to be a few decades ago. A much smaller proportion of the world's economy, population, or military power.

alephnerdyesterday at 4:24 PM

> How does this statement make sense though? I don't see the A -> B. The US pretty clearly does not want to see a Russian loss either, and seems more fine with Ukraine losing.

Despite Trump, the US (and rivals of China like South Korea and Japan) have continued to supply the Ukrainian armed forces and their allies like Poland and Romania.

A protracted Russia-Ukraine War with the balance of power in favor of Russia means the US, SK, and JP remain bogged supplying Ukraine and it's allies like Poland and Romania, instead of diverting stock to the Asian front.

Additionally, China and Russia are increasingly collaborating to respond against Japan should a conflict occur [0] and North Korea is already an active participant in the Russia-Ukraine War.

> It should depends on how much the US wants Europe?

The issue is both the US and China view the EU as a regional power that can be pushed around - not as an entity that can retain strategic autonomy.

This is the crux of the EU's current diplomatic malaise - neither the US nor China view the EU as an equal, but rather, as a junior partner.

> Perhaps I'm just really daft

I won't say daft, but the issue is Europeans view themselves as deserving of being on the same table as the Americans and Chinese. Neither the Americans or Chinese see it that way now.

In order for the EU to build strategic autonomy, some very painful steps need to be taken which simply aren't being taken (as Draghi pessimistically pointed out a couple months ago) [1].

Additionally, periphery regions of the EU have increasingly started operating independently of the rest of the EU - as with China's CSPs with Spain [2] and Hungary [3]; Israel+India's defense alliances with Greece [4] and Cyprus [5] against Turkiye; and Poland coming out against committing resources to defend Greenland [6] - so a unified EU response is steadily degrading as members decide to take defense matters into their own hands.

Basically, if a naval standoff between Greece and Turkiye was to arise in the next 6 months in the Aegean Sea, would the rest of the EU sanction Turkiye (and thus lose a major defense partner in Ukraine [7][8][9] and the Baltics [10]) or ignore Turkiye (and thus destroy the EU and NATO defense commitment).

[0] - https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-russia-discuss-ukr...

[1] - https://www.france24.com/en/tv-shows/business/20250916-mario...

[2] - http://en.cppcc.gov.cn/2025-11/13/c_1140641.htm

[3] - https://english.www.gov.cn/news/202405/10/content_WS663d3b83...

[4] - https://geetha.mil.gr/kyklos-synomilion-staff-talks-kai-ypog...

[5] - https://www.bankingnews.gr/amyna-diplomatia/articles/851003/...

[6] - https://www.reuters.com/world/poland-will-not-send-soldiers-...

[7] - https://ukrainesarmsmonitor.substack.com/p/ukraine-turkiye-s...

[8] - https://www.cats-network.eu/publication/ukraine-turkey-strat...

[9] - https://www.rnbo.gov.ua/en/Diialnist/3345.html

[10] - https://www.turkishminute.com/2026/01/13/nato-asks-turkey-to...

show 2 replies