logoalt Hacker News

Traubenfuchstoday at 2:22 PM1 replyview on HN

They are missing an aspect of the human mind that the majority of humans have. It's defined as the "inability" to do something most humans can do. Research on cognitive performance shows it's most likely connected to worse memory. Some studies show reduced social skills. Then there are the deficits in autobiographical memory. It's progressive form is indicative of dementia.

How exactly is this anything but a pathology?


Replies

bondarchuktoday at 3:02 PM

I think it's weird to call an aspect of mental functioning a pathology simply because it's not the majority, regardless of any impairment in normal functioning. Depending on how you slice definitions many many things are in the minority.

Those studies, well, I'd have to see them. There's the risk that people for whom (e.g.) memory is accompanied by imagery automatically assume that imagery is required for memory. Vague correlations with social functioning can be drawn for nearly anything.

Regarding dementia: obviously the disappearance of imagery in someone who used to have it is very different from someone who never had it.