logoalt Hacker News

unglaublichtoday at 5:41 PM11 repliesview on HN

I think JPEG XL's naming was unfortunate. People want to associate new image formats with leanness, lightness, efficiency.


Replies

fleabitdevtoday at 6:43 PM

There was a constraint - since 2009, the Joint Photographic Experts Group had published JPEG XR, JPEG XT and JPEG XS, and they were probably reluctant to break that naming scheme.

They're running out of good options, but I hope they stick with it long enough to release "JPEG XP" :-)

show 4 replies
snowramtoday at 5:46 PM

Considering "jpeg" has become the shorthand for "digital picture", it would be a shame not to capitalise on it.

show 2 replies
F3nd0today at 7:41 PM

It seems to me this point of discussion always tends to get way too much focus. Should it really raise concern?

Of all the people who interact with image formats in some way, how many do even know what an image format is? How many even notice they’ve got different names? How many even give them any consideration? And out of those, how many are immediately going to think JPEG XL must be big, heavy and inefficient? And out of those, how many are going to stop there without considering that maybe the new image format could actually be pretty good? Sure, there might be some, but I really don’t think it’s a fraction of a significant size.

Moreover, how many people in said fraction are going to remember the name (and thus perhaps the format) far more easily by remembering it’s got such a stupid name?

bobmcnamaratoday at 5:49 PM

I found it unfortunate because it's not a JPEG.

show 1 reply
OscarTheGrinchtoday at 6:06 PM

Crappy as a .jpg, only bigger.

Actually, I remember when JPEG XL came out, and I just thought: cool, file that one away for when I have a really big image I need to display. Which turned out to be never.

Names have consequences.

show 2 replies
edflsafoiewqtoday at 7:30 PM

Just call it JXL.

show 1 reply
DominoTreetoday at 8:14 PM

JPEG 15 Pro Max

catskulltoday at 5:54 PM

μJPEG

bigbuppotoday at 8:06 PM

And yet WEBP decided to associate itself with urine, which google then forced on everyone using their monopoly power.

formerly_proventoday at 6:44 PM

Nobody can keep you from forking the spec and calling yours JPEG SM.

show 2 replies
Almondsetattoday at 5:46 PM

Do you have anything to back this up?