logoalt Hacker News

SpaceX lowering orbits of 4,400 Starlink satellites for safety's sake

36 pointsby thread_idtoday at 8:21 AM35 commentsview on HN

Comments

neloxtoday at 11:42 AM

What’s the plan as the solar maximum returns?

choegertoday at 10:15 AM

I think it's important to note that not all collisions are equally dangerous. Consider a sat on a polar orbit colliding with one on a equatorial orbit. Or two satellites on different directions. That is going to be spectacular. Otoh, these kind of collisions are unlikely and should be manageable by just assigning certain shells (say 5km) for every possible direction and orientation.

If two Starlink satellites collide that go roughly in the same direction, it's not exactly a huge problem.

I think the biggest issue is to coordinate this and potentially disallow some excentric orbits.

aucisson_masquetoday at 9:31 AM

There are so many satellites in orbit that there is a pretty good chance that if even one was to be hit by something and explode in many pieces, it would crash another one and then another one until there is nothing left.

The nasa is pretty scared of it, so is SpaceX.

show 6 replies
Jean-Papoulostoday at 8:57 AM

From a comment :

>The first move in the coming WWIII, where the emperors try to expand their empires militaril,y will be to wipe out any orbit with Starlink satellites.

I find this highly unlikely, given Starlink is soon to reached 10k satellites and will continue to grow. Why expand 10 000 ballistic missiles to bring down one of many communications networks ?

show 6 replies