logoalt Hacker News

wpietritoday at 1:47 PM1 replyview on HN

No society can function without enforced rules. Most people do the pro-social thing most of the time. But for the rest, society must create negative experiences that help train people to do the right thing.

What negative experience do you think should instead be created for people breaking these rules?


Replies

weinzierltoday at 3:55 PM

Temporary or permanent social exclusion, and consequently the loss of future cooperative benefits.

A permanent public internet pillory isn’t just useless against the worst offenders, who are shameless anyway. It’s also permanently damaging to those who are still learning societal norms.

The Ghostty AI policy lacks any nuance in this regard. No consideration for the age or experience of the offender. No consideration for how serious the offense actually was.