logoalt Hacker News

lxgryesterday at 11:53 PM2 repliesview on HN

I just don’t think that’s a reasonable expectation of a telecommunications tool, so yeah, I think it’s a fair change well within the norms and expectations of an instant messenger.

You should get to control how/ to whom your data is distributed, but also requiring these recipients to only use software and services of your choosing seems excessive. Platform lock-in at this point seems like the much greater harm.

I could see the case for a small indicator in the contact details that they’re using a third-party client, but anything more (green bubbles?) would be counterproductive.


Replies

mlrtimetoday at 2:33 AM

It's not requiring, thats the point of BirdyChat, right? You just have to opt-in to use it.

dmitrygrtoday at 12:34 AM

i did not ask for green bubbles, nor did whatsapp implement that. they let me opt-in to communicate with questionable clients and i am here for it.