logoalt Hacker News

dist-epochyesterday at 12:13 PM3 repliesview on HN

In the past the elite would rule the plebs by saying "God says so, so you must do this".

Today the elites rule the plebs by saying "Science sasy so, so you must do this".

Author doesn't seem to understand this, the purpose of research papers is to be gospel, something to be believed, not scrutinized.


Replies

graemepyesterday at 12:39 PM

In fact, religious ideas (at least in Europe) were often in opposition to the ruling elite (and still are) and even inspired rebellion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Ball_(priest)

There is a reason scriptures were kept away from the oppressed, or only made available to them in a heavily censored form (e.g. the Slaves Bible).

abananayesterday at 12:21 PM

That's a very good point. Some of what's called "science" today, in popular media and coming from governments, is religion. "We know all, do not question us." It's the common problem of headlines along the lines of "scientists say" or "The Science says", which should always be a red flag - but the majority of people believe it.

Throaway1982yesterday at 3:14 PM

A little more complicated than that.

In the past, the elites said "don't read the religious texts, WE will tell you what's in them."

show 2 replies