logoalt Hacker News

pbreityesterday at 10:30 PM4 repliesview on HN

Isn't it the opposite? Landing stress a sub-section of the runway while departures stress a larger portion?

I'd be surprised that a heavier plane on takeoff exerts more force on the runway than a lighter plane landing.

And as the departing plane goes faster, doesn't the lift take stress off the runway?


Replies

duskwuffyesterday at 10:53 PM

> And as the departing plane goes faster, doesn't the lift take stress off the runway?

Only for a short period between rotation and liftoff. Most of the takeoff roll is spent building up horizontal speed; the pilot doesn't command the aircraft to pitch up before it's ready to lift off.

show 1 reply
rtkweyesterday at 10:42 PM

Planes all start their take off from basically the same position and stress the whole runway, slowly lowering as lift increases, but at their highest weight.

show 1 reply
pc86yesterday at 10:35 PM

It's the same principle as walking on snow in normal shoes vs. snow shoes. Taking off is normal shoes, a lot of pressure concentrated at the very first part of the runway. Landing is snow shoes because it's distributed across more of the physical surface, and the plane weighs a lot less when it lands anyway.

tasty_freezetoday at 12:16 AM

Watch the video. He says for long range flights, fuel is half of the total weight of the plane.