logoalt Hacker News

convolvatronyesterday at 11:46 PM3 repliesview on HN

I dont think it's the same at all. when weaving was displaced, yes some people were pissed about losing their livelihood, but the quality of the cloth didn't diminish.

when CNC came for machining, no one really bitched, because the computers were just removing the time consuming effort of moving screws by hand.

when computers write code, or screenplays, the quality right now is objectively much worse. that might change, but claims that we're at the point where computers can meaningfully displace that work are pretty weak.

sure that might change.


Replies

gbear605today at 12:08 AM

Cloth absolutely has gotten worse over the last two hundred years since industrialization. It's also orders of magnitude cheaper, making it worth it, and certainly new types of cloth are available that weren't before, but we're not better off in every possible way.

show 1 reply
odo1242today at 12:08 AM

The result being worse generally doesn't stop humans from being displaced. Clothes made today are notably worse than the handmade ones.

show 1 reply
fwipyesterday at 11:56 PM

The available quality of cloth did, in fact, diminish.

show 1 reply