logoalt Hacker News

iugtmkbdfil834today at 2:55 PM11 repliesview on HN

Allow me to offer some words of wisdom. If you help building weapons to be used against $currently_designated_bad_people, you can rest assured that given enough time, those weapons will be used against you. I am watching all this with a mild sense of bemusement.


Replies

mekdoonggitoday at 2:59 PM

A NYT columnist Jamelle Bouie suggested (in jest) that the next Democrat administration send armed IRS agents to gated communities in Florida, to "investigate tax fraud".

But this is exactly why all citizens should be concerned about the infringement of rights happening in Minnesota. If it is allowed without prosecution, you are next.

show 9 replies
gcanyontoday at 5:57 PM

The problem I was listening to a historian discuss the other day is that we're stuck in a cycle of:

   1. Republican breaks norms/laws
   2. Democrat cleans up after, but by *not* breaking norms, doesn't go far enough to actually undo all the damage
   3. We end up with a more broken governmental configuration, and head back to (1)
They said this pattern goes back to Nixon.
show 1 reply
nathan_comptontoday at 3:31 PM

How tedious. I don't disagree, fundamentally, with your message, but this internet smart guy thing people do where they use things like $variables to signal that they are above everything and anyone who things X is bad or good just isn't smart enough to see things in the abstract really sucks. And I am very glad you are mildly bemused by people getting shot in the streets, the deterioration of democratic norms that might spiral into more violence and actual, real life, people getting fucked up. Very cool of you.

show 1 reply
culitoday at 4:37 PM

This is called "boomerang theory" in sociology

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_boomerang

show 1 reply
jimbokuntoday at 6:47 PM

This seems to be an argument that defense spending is never legitimate?

topspintoday at 4:40 PM

> those weapons will be used against you

On the matter of social media "moderation," this is the phase you're actually in, right now.

agilobtoday at 8:04 PM

>If you help building weapons to be used against $currently_designated_bad_people

Democrats would really love some extra help from WikiLeaks right now, if only not Bidens administration who helped to extradite Julian.

show 1 reply
ActorNightlytoday at 4:25 PM

Tik Tok wasn't built to be used as a weapon though.

show 2 replies
dogleashtoday at 6:15 PM

Corollary: building a benign system that doesn't make the levers of control as small and close to the user as possible, is inviting someone with ulterior motives to use those controls.

lingrush4today at 3:13 PM

And you think they won't be used against me if I don't help build them?

Seems unlikely.

If the implication is that the tools won't exist if I don't build them, that's beyond a pipe dream. We'll never get a globe of 8 billion people to agree unanimously on anything. Let alone agreeing not to build something that gives them power over their adversaries.

show 1 reply
guywithahattoday at 3:51 PM

The $currently_designated_bad_people however are criminal illegal aliens. Sometimes we have to create mechanisms to go after pedophiles and rapists, and we just have to trust the system well enough to assume these tools won't be used to go after good people. I mean the bar for ICE is so outrageously high it's hard to see a world where it's lowered far enough to go after someone like me.

show 3 replies