logoalt Hacker News

bee_rideryesterday at 5:33 PM2 repliesview on HN

This seems to be implying that the creation of Wayland had some motivation that was essentially malicious toward X. Is that right?


Replies

gmuecklyesterday at 6:14 PM

This question sounds to me like you suspect some outright evil getting projected here. That would go too far. The wayland project tried to get the support of X developers early so that they could become a sort of "blessed" X successor early on. Plenty of earlier replacement attempts have failed because they couldn't get bigger community support, so this had to be part of a successful strategy. Any detrimental effects on X from that move were never a direct goal, as far as I am aware, just a consequence.

show 2 replies
badsectoraculayesterday at 6:20 PM

Wanting developers to switch projects doesn't have to be malicious, in fact personally i doubt there were any bad intentions in place, the developers of Wayland most likely think they're doing the right thing.