logoalt Hacker News

robin_realayesterday at 7:04 PM3 repliesview on HN

Ask the indigenous Americans.


Replies

spankaleeyesterday at 7:11 PM

I think if you're going to argue that we shouldn't have contemporary immigration because of the harm to native Americans, then you should show what harm is caused _now_, that native Americans actually oppose immigration, and probably that you support other ways of helping them like giving them land back.

throwaway173738yesterday at 7:13 PM

If you go back far enough everyone comes from a line of invaders, so I fail to see how this contributes to anything.

gavin-1yesterday at 7:18 PM

Not a fair comparison.

Immigrants are not killing Americans en masse nor taking the land by force.