logoalt Hacker News

JuniperMesosyesterday at 7:27 PM3 repliesview on HN

I'm not claiming that this is a step in the direction of fixing academia; I'm claiming that, because academia is currently broken, we shouldn't assume that the ~10k people who got PhDs under the current system are people doing actually-valuable work for the federal government and ultimately the American people.


Replies

checker659yesterday at 7:51 PM

Would you have said the same for folks doing NLP circa 2015?

show 1 reply
rwyinuseyesterday at 7:30 PM

Knowing current administration anti-science approach to things like climate and health, I wouldn't be all at surprised if many of those who left academia were ones producing quality work that just didn't align with Trump admin's ideology.

show 3 replies
throwaway2056yesterday at 7:45 PM

> 'm not claiming that this is a step in the direction of fixing academia; I'm claiming that, because academia is currently broken, we shouldn't assume that the

Why?

If you go that far then

- senate

- scotus

- violence

- SV

- tech bros

- lies about AI

What is not broken.

The idea of academia is it is an investment. Look at internet, DoE, Genome, vaccines - a lot from academia. Companies barely do that.

show 1 reply