logoalt Hacker News

bayindirhyesterday at 7:46 PM1 replyview on HN

You're absolutely right, but considering Windows requirements drive the PC spec, this capability can be used to force Linux distributions in bad ways.

So, some of the people doing "typical HN rage-posting about DRM" are also absolutely right.

The capabilities locking down macOS and iOS and related hardware also can be used for good, but they are not used for that.


Replies

bri3dyesterday at 7:56 PM

> but considering Windows requirements drive the PC spec, this capability can be used to force Linux distributions in bad ways

What do you mean by this?

Is the concern that systemd is suddenly going to require that users enable some kind of attestation functionality? That making attestation possible or easier is going to cause third parties to start requiring it for client machines running Linux? This doesn't even really seem to be a goal; there's not really money to be made there.

As far as I can tell the sales pitch here is literally "we make it so you can assure the machines running in your datacenter are doing what they say they are," which seems pretty nice to me, and the perversions of this to erode user rights are either just as likely as they ever were or incredibly strange edge cases.

show 1 reply