alt Hacker NewsI feel like I have talked to Embedding-shape on Hackernews quite a lot that I recognize him. So it was a proud like moment when I saw his hackernews & github comments on a youtube video [0]about the recent cursor thing
It's great to see him make this. I didn't know that he had a blog but looks good to me. Bookmarked now.
I feel like although Cursor burned 5 million$, we saw that and now Embedding shapes takeaway
If one person with one agent can produce equal or better results than "hundreds of agents for weeks", then the answer to the question: "Can we scale autonomous coding by throwing more agents at a problem?", probably has a more pessimistic answer than some expected.
Effectively to me this feels like answering the query which was being what if we have thousands of AI agents who can build a complex project autonomously with no Human. That idea seems dead now. Humans being in the loop will have a much higher productivity and end result.
I feel like the lure behind the Cursor project was to find if its able to replace humans completely in a extremely large project and the answer's right now no (and I have a feeling [bias?] that the answer's gonna stay that way)
Emsh I have a question tho, can you tell me about your background if possible? Have you been involved in browser development or any related endeavours or was this a first new one for you? From what I can feel/have talked with you, I do feel like the answer's yes that you have worked in browser space but I am still curious to know the answer.
A question which is coming to my mind is how much would be the difference between 1 expert human 1 agent and 1 (non expert) say Junior dev human 1 agent and 1 completely non expert say a normal person/less techie person 1 agent go?
What are your guys prediction on it?
How would the economics of becoming an "expert" or becoming a jack of all trades (junior dev) in a field fare with this new technology/toy that we got.
how much productivity gains could be from 1 non expert -> junior dev and the same question for junior -> senior dev in this particular context
[0] Cursor Is Lying To Developers… : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7s_CaI93Mo
I don't think the Cursor thing was about replacing humans entirely.
(If it was that's bad news for them as a company that sells tools to human developers!)
It was about scaling coding agents up to much larger projects by coordinating and running them in parallel. They chose a web browser for that not because they wanted to build a web browser, but because it seemed like the ideal example of a well specified but enormous (million line+) project which multiple parallel agents could take on where a single agent wouldn't be able to make progress.
embedding-shape's project here disproves that last bit - that you need parallel agents to build a competent web renderer - by achieving a more impressive result with just one Codex agent in a few days.