alt Hacker NewsSketchUp was my go to for a while but I'm done with parametric personally, trying to fix meshes for 3D printing... time I grow up and use something like Fusion360 seems like or onshape. Still it was good/simple enough for non-round shapes in SketchUp except they have some kind of memory leak/bug at least for the 2017 version. But I guess quit being cheap and buy a modern copy on my part.
Edit: oh I guess sketchup is a surface modeler weird thought it was parametric this whole time, lol someone else said it's a polygon modeler
Yeah I don't know what parametric modeling is apparently, I use a mouse/calipers to model stuff not parameters
There is a solid validator plugin you use before you export an STL to make sure the mesh is closed/a manifold
Replies
SketchUp uses direct modelling, not parametric modelling. I think they even got some patents on direct modelling.
It's using a constructive solid geometry system. You can add and subtract volumes. Making a hole is subtracting a volume. This has classically been numeric roundoff hell, where points that should coincide and surfaces which should touch don't get handled properly due to numerical error. The geometry engine is Manifold, which guarantees watertight meshes from boolean operations.
Ah. That's what's doing the constructive solid geometry. Here's the 2009 PhD thesis behind the object merge and difference algorithms inside Manifold. Nice. At last, soundness. This is a long-standing problem. And now there's an open source implementation. Manifold itself is in C++, not Rust, though.
None of this is parametric. That's a different problem. That's where you put in constraints such as A is perpendicular to B, B is 100mm from C, etc., and the constraint solver tries to satisfy all the constraints. Change a dimension and everything adjusts to preserve the constraints. Parametric CAD is all about constraint solving and expressing conflicts to the user. Autodesk Inventor, Fusion, etc. have good constraint solvers.
[1] https://github.com/elalish/manifold/blob/master/docs/RobustB...