logoalt Hacker News

mw888today at 2:15 AM6 repliesview on HN

There seems to be wild speculation about freedom of speech rights or hacking Signal.

The FBI simply joined groupchats and read them. This is trivial stuff.


Replies

glaughtoday at 4:13 AM

Do you mean just technically trivial? I agree with that.

If you mean more broadly trivial, I see that quite differently. An administration that has repeatedly abused its power in order to intimidate and punish political opponents is opening an investigation into grassroots political opponents. That feels worth being concerned about.

show 3 replies
RobRiveratoday at 4:26 AM

Yea, I just assume any easily joinable movement like this is a honeypot of sorts.

BurningFrogtoday at 2:44 AM

Seems like there are hundreds of people in those groups.

Can't be hard to get into for some skilled undercover cops. TV shows have shown me they do these things all the time!

show 1 reply
trollbridgetoday at 2:24 AM

Or just got control of 1 person’s phone/account.

lynndotpytoday at 3:59 AM

More specifically, right-wing agitators joined the chats and posted screenshots online.

trhwaytoday at 2:56 AM

>The FBI simply

i don't think an investigation by FBI has ever been "simply" to the subjects of such an investigation. And to show bang-for-the-buck the "simply reading chat" officers would have to bring at least some fish, i.e. federal charges, from such a reading expedition.

In general it sounds very familiar - any opposition is a crime of impeding and obstruction. Just like in Russia where any opposition is a crime of discreditation at best or even worse - a crime of extremism/terrorism/treason.

show 1 reply